Timing issues on the PSAT Math section usually stem from either getting stuck on hard problems or spending too much time on setup and calculation. A tutor can teach you strategic approaches like identifying which problems to tackle first, recognizing when to skip and return later, and using shortcuts for common question types. Practice with full-length tests under timed conditions is essential—this builds the automaticity you need so easier problems feel almost instinctive, leaving more time for complex ones.

The best way is to take a full practice PSAT and review your results by topic—the College Board breaks down performance by Heart of Algebra, Problem Solving and Data Analysis, Passport to Advanced Math, and Additional Topics. Once you identify which areas are dragging your score down, a tutor can drill into those specific concepts with targeted practice and explanations tailored to how you learn. Many students are surprised to find their weak spots aren't where they thought—a diagnostic approach prevents wasting time on topics you already know.

Your first session is about assessment and planning. Expect to work through some PSAT Math problems so your tutor can see your approach, identify where you get stuck, and understand your learning style. Together, you'll discuss your goals (Are you aiming for a specific score? Preparing for the SAT later?), review your practice test results if you have them, and create a customized study plan that fits your timeline. This foundation ensures every session after that is laser-focused on what actually moves your score.

Test anxiety often stems from feeling unprepared or unsure of your approach—tutoring directly addresses both. By building genuine mastery of concepts and practicing with real PSAT questions repeatedly, you develop confidence that carries into test day. Your tutor can also teach you practical strategies like managing difficult problems without panic, pacing yourself so you're not rushed, and recognizing that the PSAT is designed to have hard questions (everyone struggles with some). Knowing you've practiced thoroughly is one of the best anxiety reducers.

A solid approach is to take a diagnostic practice test at the start to establish your baseline, then take full-length tests every 2-3 weeks as you work through tutoring. This frequency lets you track progress, identify emerging patterns in your mistakes, and get comfortable with the actual test format and timing. Between full tests, focus on targeted practice with specific question types and concepts—this mix of diagnostic testing and focused drilling is more effective than either alone.

Look for someone with strong math credentials (ideally a degree in math or related field) and proven experience preparing students for standardized tests, particularly the PSAT and SAT. They should be familiar with the current PSAT format, understand the College Board's question design, and have a track record of helping students improve. Varsity Tutors connects you with expert tutors who specialize in PSAT Math and can explain not just how to solve problems, but why the test is designed the way it is—that insight is what builds both skill and confidence.

For meaningful improvement, aim for 3-5 hours per week over 8-12 weeks leading up to test day—this breaks down to roughly one tutoring session (1-2 hours) plus independent practice. If you're starting further out or have significant gaps to close, you might invest more upfront. The key is consistency over intensity; steady weekly practice with spaced repetition is far more effective than cramming. Your tutor will help you build a realistic schedule that fits your other commitments while keeping momentum going.